The Judges

An independent eye on every frame

Films are judged by professional filmmakers and documentary experts: working artists, not committee members.

A cinematographer pulls focus · Photo: Robin Férand · CC BY 3.0

The panel for the 2026–27 cycle will be announced this fall.

What they look for

Five criteria, equally weighted

Storytelling

A clear, disciplined narrative that earns the audience’s attention.

Research

Depth of reporting, accuracy, and fairness to the people on screen.

Technical quality

Cinematography, sound, editing, production values.

Originality

A subject pursued with curiosity, and a film only its maker could have made.

Documentary craft

Command of the form: observation, structure, and letting the story speak.